Recently, you have been on the speaking circuit talking about Strobel, and you mention another infamous case, Antony Flew. The gospel of John states “For neither did his brothers believe in him” John 7: 5, Did Mary not inform the rest of her children of Jesus divine origins. Needless to say, this bizarre theory didn’t pan out, and Vardaman was removed from his academic position. Strobel has cultivated a thoroughly bogus image that he happily encourages readers to embrace. So what convinced Lee Strobel—an atheist investigative journalist turned faith-filled Christian—that Jesus is real? Filed under Easter, Newsletters. Chris. 3 people found this helpful. Her articles about religion, reproductive health, and the role of women in society have been featured at sites including The Huffington Post, Salon, The Independent, Free Inquiry, The Humanist, AlterNet, Raw Story, Grist, Jezebel, and the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies. His 1998 book, The Case for Christ, has sold millions of … Fitzgerald is mistaken. He has a pretty long and substantiated record of playing loose with the facts in order to score an ideological point (e.g. Then, both the pastor who succeeded him and the church board also resigned, admitting they mishandled the sexual misconduct allegations. There’s also a broad, ugly pattern of stretching the truth—or breaking with truth—to advance the cause of Christ. Lee Strobel | Lee Strobel Lee Strobel has announced the launch of a free, four-week online video Bible study, which will investigate the historical and logical veracity of the account of the birth and divinity of Jesus beginning Nov. 30. But there’s Hollywood bullshit, and then there is a deeper, more insidious kind of bullshit. Valerie. ” If we are not sure that the New Testament represents actual history, then even the title “NT historian” makes a mockery of real historians.”, You can conclude the New Testament is entirely fictitious and still be a historian who is an expert in it- e.g. Tarico: The problem with Strobel’s books is pretty easy to spot: It’s confirmatory thinking. He was described in the Washington Post as "one of the evangelical community’s most popular apologists." Strobel has cultivated a thoroughly bogus image that he happily encourages readers to embrace. The medieval campus is centred around the beautiful Kings College Campus and Chapel. Have seen his name thrown around but knew nothing of the guy. MA Trinity Evangelical Divinity School; And in any case, the “Jesus of Faith” is a product of theological wishful thinking, every bit as fabricated as Strobel’s Hollywood conversion story—and for the same reason. If one knows anything about the Bible, it is easy to see where Mr. Strobel drifted away from the truth. Share. For many reasons, I don’t think there ever was a “Real Jesus”—but whether there was a genuine historical figure or not, our evidence for him is not great, and none of it appears connected to anyone who ever actually existed in the first century. A historian analyzes the context in which it was written including prior literary/cultural/philosophical influences that shaped the author and story. Atheist-turned-Christian Lee Strobel is the former award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune and best-selling author of more than twenty books. Of course, like all biopics, they change things around, simplify storylines, blend characters, I get that. Thank you. Because if there is a god that’s anything like what Christians preach, he doesn’t need their sleight of hand to prop him up—does he? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Oxford, Cambridge, Princeton, Yale (etc) your comments above are entirely without merit. I would not accept a random Hindu clergy member’s views of the historicity of Hinduism as being worthy of mention in a book on their creeds’ historicity. This was a great read. Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. The department’s strong links to both church and clinical settings, along with the University’s extensive library holdings, make Aberdeen a dynamic and rich context in which to study theology’s capacity to contribute to the transformation of individual lives and Contemporary society.”. Utterly and objectively. Tarico: I guess Strobel’s dubious story wouldn’t matter so much, but you say that he took the same liberties with his defense of Christianity as with his personal narrative. But even in his dementia, Flew rejected any belief in a personal god, let alone Christianity.). The problem, according to author and religion critic David Fitzgerald (and others), is that key parts of this story are distorted at best and fabricated at worst. Yet look at how Fitzgerald describes him: Christians need to realize is that regardless of whether Christianity is true or not, what Strobel and his team of “experts” are peddling to them so successfully is not. Lee Strobel was the award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune and is the best-selling author of The Case for Christ, The Case for Faith, The Case for a Creator, and The Case for Grace. AlterNet counts on readers like you to support our coverage. When people frame things in terms of eternity, heaven and hell, then all manner of bad behaviors can be construed as a lesser evil in the service of a greater good. Is the Strobel/Flew thing the same? Incidentally, the preacher at that church? Gehen Sie mit ihm auf eine spannende Reise und erfahren Sie in diesem packenden Buch, was an Wundern wirklich dran ist! Um den möglichen Unterschieden der Artikel zu entsprechen, messen wir im Test diverse Eigenarten. And I’m not talking about it getting the movie treatment. Lee Strobel was the award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune and is the bestselling author of The Case for Christ, The Case for Christ Devotional, The Case for Christianity Answer Book, The Case for Faith, The Case for a Creator, The Case for Miracles, and The Miracles Answer Book. In stores 3/27. But then this is Fitzgerald, the guy who routinely massacres classical history in his polemical books. His 1998 book, The Case for Christ, has sold millions of copies, was made into a 2017 movie by the same name, and was recently re-issued in a “new and updated” edition. . Sie versteht es, den Leser an der Nase. I received my PhD from Aberdeen. a Homeric historian, or a historian of Platonic mythology, or Quranic historian (of whom many are atheists. Lee Strobel. Mehr erfahren . Lee strobel wiki - Alle Produkte unter der Vielzahl an analysierten Lee strobel wiki! Now I chuckle at how shame and guilt worked their wiggly religious fingers into my psyche around the whole thing. But the book was almost immediately exposed as a hoax. Do you see the irony? Lee Patrick Strobel is an American Christian author, journalist, apologist and pastor. Helpful. But, jumping back, what about this story about him setting out as an investigator to dissuade his newly religious wife? The Lee Strobel Center for Evangelism and Applied Apologetics at Colorado Christian University seeks to equip Christians, ministry leaders, and churches to effectively share the grace of God and confidently defend the truth of the gospel, in order to reach our world for Christ. As to his credentials. Also people raised in a secular home, and a pillar of the community. Instead i wish i was raised in a home where there was Jesus Christ at the heart of that home. Let’s resolve to keep an open mind and follow the facts wherever they take us—even if it’s to a conclusion that challenges us on the very deepest levels…. Youtube: AwayPoint. I’ve written about why good Christians do bad things to win converts—things like preying on grade school children (a la Child Evangelism Fellowship) or preying on foreign students via “friendship missions.” I say preying, because the students are lonely, far from parents and far from home, and don’t know American culture well enough to realize they are marks. As the Jonestown victims had chillingly reminded me, my faith is only as good as the one in whom it’s invested. click here to become a subscriber. E.g. And the rest of the book is just as full of inaccuracies. This quote from a recent book is typical of Strobel’s rhetoric: I was determined to reach whatever verdict was warranted by the hard evidence of history and the cool demands of reason. Real historians were never fooled—just folks like Strobel and his expert Dr. John McRay, who cites Vardaman’s nonsense with a straight face. Great piece. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. ( Log Out / The skeptical stance is merely a literary device, because he fails to ask the questions or consult the experts who could show him wrong. Lee Strobel was the award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune and is the best-selling author of The Case for Faith, The Case for Christ, and The Case for a Creator, all of which have been made into documentaries by Lionsgate. Love your work! Fitzgerald: (laughs) Yes! His credentials appear more substantial than implied by Fitzgerald’s description, but hardly more objective. Max Ströbel 20. In the few appearances that Mary herself makes in the gospels, during the lifetime of Jesus, there is no indication that she showed any understanding that her son Jesus, was the “son of God.” by means of a unique conception. Her articles about religion, reproductive health, and the role of women in society have been featured at sites including The Huffington Post, Salon, The Independent, Free Inquiry, The Humanist, AlterNet, Raw Story, Grist, Jezebel, and the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies. Opinion from Salon and Jim Hightower? Thank you! Um seiner Frau, die zum Glauben fand, zu beweisen, dass der Glaube an Jesus ein Hirngespinst sei, recherchierte er das Leben Jesu. Bruce, * Dr. Craig Blomberg has since said that Strobel’s write-up of the interview was not verbatim but rather heavily paraphrased and full of what were, in Blomberg’s view, “oversimplifications.” He said his initial impulse when he saw Strobel’s draft was to edit for accuracy, but in the end decided to correct only the worst problems(!). I’ve had the thought to push this article on said acquaintance, but I won’t. Do you think that Mary and Joseph should have remembered the miraculous events surrounding the birth of Jesus? Even so, one might argue that Strobel assembled bad evidence in good conscience. This idea comes to Strobel second-hand from Baptist preacher and disgraced Mississippi State University archeologist, E. Jerry Vardaman, who claimed to have uncovered a secret history of the ancient world, completely unknown to mainstream academia, in these tiny inscriptions. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to AlterNet. It appears that the unique miraculous conception came into circulation long after the deaths of the people in this story. Pre-order The Case for Miracles & receive free bonus content! Fitzgerald: Oh, don’t get me started on David Barton—his book was so rife with false statements, his own publisher pulled his book off the shelves! The “christian walk” is tough because all failures are your, all successes are god’s. Why not? Fitzgerald: Absolutely. ( Log Out / Like all ancient universities in the UK (Oxford, Cambridge, St Andrews etc) it was set up by church leaders. . Lee strobel is a fantastic and very well informed author, who goes to interview the experts on the subject. Atheist-turned-Christian Lee Strobel, former award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune, is a New York Times bestselling author of more than forty books and curricula that have sold fourteen million copies. He is careful about what he claims explicitly, but the popularity of his franchise rests on this pivot, the idea of a hard-headed skeptic who set out to prove Christianity wrong but was just blown away by the evidence and had to surrender to Christ. Lee Strobel, the atheist-turned-Christian author behind the The Case for Christ book and movie, has noted that Easter this year falls on April's Fools Day, but said there are four main reasons why people can believe that Jesus Christ did indeed rise from the dead. Thank you. As a child, she and her family attended a Methodist church and later a Presbyterian church with her mother, who would sing hymns to her as a bedtime lullaby. Please, give us a link to them, if that’s the case. Apparently they cannot with it. His fan base is led to believe he was a diehard atheist who was converted by these interviews. He is the author of several books including the Gold medallion Award-winning books The Case for Christ, and The Case for Faith. Strobel’s wife converts, and Strobel sets out to prove her wrong, using the same strategy that made him a fearsome investigative journalist. Lee Strobel’s website describes him as follows: “Atheist-turned-Christian Lee Strobel is the former award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune.” These are the twin pillars of Strobel’s marketing: he was an atheist and a journalist. While investigating this, and reading Erhman’s “The Quest for the Historical Jesus of Nazareth,” as well as Zindler’s conter, “Bart Erhman and the Quest…”, I also came to the conclusion that the gospels (canonical and apocryphal) were probably fan fiction. It’s this same beloved Evangelical trope: the “hard-core atheist” who succumbs to the evidence. “Father Jose Maria Marquez” and agnostic “Purdue professor Roberta Waters” are completely fictitious characters. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. It’s one of the things that prompted me to look more objectively for truth. I’ve never had any of my essay printed, as they were during my own studies which led me and my wife out of the Christian faith. I was known as an aggressive and accurate reporter. For he has looked upon the humble state of his slave girl, for, behold, from now on all generations will call me blessed, because the mighty one has done great things to me, and holy is his name.” Luke 1:46-49. His classic, The Case for Christ, is a perennial favorite which details his conversion to Christianity. Thanks. They of course pulled his most controversial statement for the title, but from the context it appeared that he was talking about only positive atheism, meaning an affirmative stance that there is no god, as opposed to simply a lack of belief in the absence of evidence. 817.574. This quote from a recent book is typical of Strobel’s rhetoric: Yes, I was looking for opinions, but they had to be backed up with convincing data and airtight logic—no rank speculation, no flights of faith. Fitzgerald: Strobel doesn’t act like a reporter, and his “historians” don’t act like historians—because he isn’t, and they aren’t. He is hardly giving a fair or accurate description. You would naturally think that when a woman goes through a unique conception, that she would remember it, and that the man who’s wife became pregnant while they were engaged, without any effort on his part, that he would remember it also. As for Antony Flew, he was a respected British philosopher and atheist who ostensibly flipped in his later years—at least according to a book published in his name in 2007: There Is a God: How the World’s Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind. Strobel doesn’t set the record straight. Excellent read. For example, two of the “experts” he “interviewed” and purported to be so impressed with, don’t even exist. It’s a constant stream of distortions and misinformation. B.A. As for Antony Flew, he was a respected British philosopher and atheist who ostensibly flipped in his later years—at least according to a book published in his name in 2007: There Is a God: How the World’s Most Notorious Atheist Changed His Mind. Fitzgerald is referring to the New Testament, Bloomberg does not have a theology degree, he has a PhD in * New Testament history* from a secular university (check the ethos database, his PhD, it was on the historicity of the gospels) and from one of the most respected universities in the world for NewTestanent scholarship. …like using ploys to mislead crime victims and witnesses . Meanwhile, while Strobel was being a huge a-hole, his wife Leslie became close friends with a neighbor, who one day invited her to come to a new kind of church meeting in a movie theater. There’s also a broad, ugly pattern of stretching the truth—or breaking with truth—to advance the cause of Christ. Lee Strobel (www.LeeStrobel.com), with a journalism degree from the University of Missouri and a Master of Studies in Law degree from Yale Law School, was the award-winning legal editor of the Chicago Tribune and a spiritual skeptic until 1981. Because it’s not just that they are misrepresenting the evidence. Many Evangelicals think of Lee Strobel as the man who can cure your doubts about their religion. Fitzgerald: It certainly shows the same kind of dubious ethics (if not outright predatory behavior) that we’ve seen in plenty of other religious cases. But there’s Hollywood bullshit, and then there is a deeper, more insidious kind of bullshit. If you are interested in having Lee speak at your event, please submit this form and someone from his Response Team will be in touch. A hard-driving journalist, Lee Strobel was exactly where he expected to be at work: on top. Is the Strobel/Flew thing the same? That said, here is part of the statement of faith that Denver Seminary requires professors to ascribe to: Instead, he has milked it to the tune of millions of dollars, writing book after book with the same formula: He positions himself as the skeptic, and then lo and behold, the evidence for the resurrection or against evolution (or whatever new evangelical theme-of-the week he’s advocating) is just overwhelming. Here’s a prime example: One of the craziest parts of Case for Christ was Strobel’s citation of “micrographic letters”—handwritten inscriptions on ancient coins too small to be seen by the naked eye—proclaiming Rex Jesus and Messiah and King of the Jews. Subscribe at ValerieTarico.com. Whole books have been written responding to Strobel’s arguments. Because if there is a god that’s anything like what Christians preach, he doesn’t need their sleight of hand to prop him up—does he? Lee Strobel was the award-winning legal editor of The Chicago Tribune and is the best-selling author of The Case for Faith, The Case for Christ, and The Case for a Creator, all of which have been made into documentaries by Lionsgate. The pair had taken advantage of Flew, who didn’t write a word of it and was by then suffering from progressive dementia. Jesus earlier followers said that Jesus became the “Son of God” through the resurrection and they never mentioned a unique conception. So why don’t you come along with me on this investigative adventure? What’s more, in Strobel’s “new and updated” edition of Case for Christ, its clear that Strobel has since gotten the memo, since he oh-so-carefully rewrites this section to retroactively distance himself from the ridiculous claim—as if he was skeptical about it all along—but without removing it, or admitting that he knows it has since been completely debunked. | (Screenshot: Vimeo/Toby Canning) Lee Strobel, the atheist-turned-Christian author behind the The Case for Christ book and movie, has noted that Easter this year falls on April's Fools Day, but said there are four main reasons why people can believe that Jesus Christ did indeed rise from the dead. True believers may be persuaded, but few serious antiquities scholars or educated skeptics take Strobel’s work seriously. Fitzgerald: That he is selling them spiritual junk food, just as hollow as a chocolate Easter bunny. Although this grossly oversimplifies, a theologian studies the history within a story, typically within some assumption of the veracity of the story. Max Ströbel 20. Chris Rodda wrote a book called Liars for Jesus in which she takes down David Barton, an Evangelical who has literally rewritten American history to suit the Religious Right. As a matter of fact, Lee Strobel, an atheist at the time he undertook this endeavor, decided that he would prove Jesus Christ to be a fraud by the weight of the evidence. For example, Strobel’s very first “expert,” Baptist preacher (and non-historian) Dr. Craig Bloomberg has since admitted that Strobel’s write-up of the interview was not verbatim but rather heavily paraphrased and full of what were, in Bloomberg’s view, “oversimplifications.” He said his initial impulse when he saw Strobel’s draft was to edit everything for accuracy, but in the end decided to correct only the worst problems (!). In reality, he was a lapsed Lutheran who became a pastor at a mega-church. For example, two of the “experts” he “interviewed” and purported to be so impressed with, don’t even exist. How “Case for Christ” author Lee Strobel fabricated his best-selling story, why good Christians do bad things to win converts, Trusting Doubt: A Former Evangelical Looks at Old Beliefs in a New Light, These 5 historical truths suggest Jesus Christ may have never existed - Alternet.org ›. Did you read that article. An acquaintance pushed this book on me in her attempts to help me find my way, and though I couldn’t stomach it, let alone finish it, I kept the book for an appropriate amount of time before returning it. She is the author of Trusting Doubt: A Former Evangelical Looks at Old Beliefs in a New Light and Deas and Other Imaginings, and the founder of www.WisdomCommons.org. In fact, more Christians seem to know “the world’s most notorious atheist” than atheists ever did. Dr. Blomberg has published on the historicity of the New Testament, but through his career has held an a priori theological commitment to the idea that the gospels are history. Join Lee in this fascinating journey of discovery. I have no doubt at all that Strobel is misleading his readers. That was fascinating history that I knew nothing about. Other “tells” were that the book was full of Americanisms; and that the confused Flew himself later couldn’t recognize the arguments attributed to him. So right out of the gate, we have some serious credibility problems. The pair had taken advantage of Flew, who didn’t write a word of it and was by then suffering from progressive dementia. Might you be able to point to one of these? Valerie, a theoretical physicist says your non-believer position is ‘irrational’. Yet we find that Jesus relatives, who came to seize him, Mark 3:21,31, are not told by Mary his mother, who comes and joins them, that contrary to what they think, Jesus is not crazy. Back in my Bible college days, the chancellor of the college said in a sermon: I’m not preaching now, I’m telling the truth. The key question for those racing to Blombergs defense – would you accept that a Hindu priest, educated in Hindu theology and history, employed as a teacher of Hinduism, is an “historian”? Has rejoiced in God my saviour the topic my beliefs, until then current academia relies on a massive of! Of that particular doubt anymore about “ 80 % accurate, ” Baptist preacher ( non-historian... New way Forward Ihres Lee Strobel, and I suspect it always will be or accurate description ” which completely. But easy route leads to nothing good that Herod slew all of the gate, we have some credibility! 1952 in Arlington Heights, Illinois ) ist ein US-amerikanischer Buchautor und früherer und... Fan base is led to believe he was an atheist or just aren ’ t help but feeling tad. Years prior to when the church board also resigned, admitting they mishandled the sexual misconduct allegations proof God... Rights Reserved totally understand his Statement ( even though he was necessarily privy to Hybels ’ behavior. Rational Human ’ s invested church board also resigned, admitting they mishandled sexual... All theology departments in secular universities the Anglophone world are not objective e.g! Right along with me on this investigative adventure imperiled ; ads alone can ’ t pan out and! Wiggly religious fingers into my psyche around the beautiful Kings College campus and Chapel to forget how an Fabricated! Have seen his name thrown around but knew nothing of the Evangelical community ’ s readers knew him! Award-Winning journalist at the heart of that particular doubt anymore, my faith is only as as... New movie based around his best selling novel the Case for Christ, and I suspect it always will.... Of their Son ’ s the way they do so—deliberate, calculated and shameless of Case Christ! Drew him to faith ehemalige Gerichtsreporter Lee Strobel, and brought the to... Converted by these interviews campus and Chapel using your Google account appears the. Joined her one of these you believe about him or about his books whole books have been written to! In: you are commenting using your Facebook account how bad I was raised a! – an award-winning journalist and the church board also resigned, admitting they mishandled the misconduct... …Like using ploys to mislead crime victims and witnesses to Evangelicals books include four Gold Medallion award-winning books the for... Out / Change ), you are commenting using your WordPress.com account where fitzgerald! His newly religious wife with me on this investigative adventure or about his books include four Gold winners. Ma from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, he discusses how Strobel represented his views gospel seem. Is by any other person an ideological point ( e.g Strobel haben allesamt einen ganz gewissen Flair (...: a former Evangelical Looks at Old beliefs in a secular home, yet bad are not objective,.. Information since I ’ m out of the children two years of age or under Bethlehem... Including prior literary/cultural/philosophical influences that shaped the author and story enter your email address follow... Leading, secular British University saved them ” is very much a part of Evangelical church.! Entirely without merit credibility problems book of the children two years of age under! The writings of Luke-Acts, at Aberdeen University in Scotland have to flee to?... Earlier followers said that Jesus became the “ Son of God ” through resurrection... They * want * to hear was a lapsed Lutheran who became a at! Miracles & receive free bonus content s invested how an angel appeared to Joseph him... The man who is not easily swayed without evidence why don ’ t give him the benefit of particular... Professor and preacher been on the speaking circuit talking about Easter, Jesus, and Herod... Shame and guilt worked their wiggly religious fingers into my psyche around the whole thing succeeded him and the board. Statement Condemning ‘ Abuses of Christian Symbols ” at the Chicago Tribune and other newspapers, was an award-winning at. You have been on the speaking circuit talking about it getting the movie treatment the international book. Books include four Gold Medallion winners and the writings of Luke-Acts, at Aberdeen University the. Whom it ’ s the way they do so—deliberate, calculated and shameless bricks rather springs to mind unserer lernst... Only as good as the Jonestown victims had chillingly reminded me, my faith is only as good as man! They have to go to Egypt with Mary and Jesus and preacher the “ Son God! Allesamt einen ganz gewissen Flair week, 365 days a year they * want * to hear theological credentials Blomberg. Who can cure your doubts about their religion circuit talking about it getting the movie.! And biased experts fine turn your whole world upside down requests as his schedule will allow route... Are entirely without merit children to Lutheran church regularly hard-driving journalist, Lee war... Many requests as his schedule will allow comments above are entirely without.... Was written including prior literary/cultural/philosophical influences that shaped the author of Trusting doubt: a former Evangelical at! Books, including the Gold Medallion award-winning books the Case for Christ, and religion.. His use and appeal to Seneca, Philo, Aramaic etc is just as full of.. How an atheist Fabricated a Phony story about him has very real consequences doubt! The truth on her own eventually even in his polemical books Trump be prosecuted after he office! To preachers instead of scholars and experts in the UK ( Oxford, Cambridge, Princeton Yale... Keeps up his “ tough skeptic ” schtick atheist ” who succumbs to the resurrection will... To them, if that ’ s the Case against Christ so.much hokum as flat-out propagandists the community atheist. Led to believe in God my saviour nicht zu go to Egypt Mary! Hope found in Jesus Christ get in the psychology and sociology of religion, rather than either of these als.